shop by category
shop by size
shop by age
Our structured satchels will add a littleladylike appeal to your office look.
Your favorite shoes: on sale now!
AMERICAN EAGLE BY PAYLESS IS NOT A PRODUCT OF AMERICAN EAGLE OUTFITTERS.
Whatever the reason, you can return it – no questions, no problem!
It's the quick, easy and free Return Policy you'll only find at Payless. Return or exchange your Payless.com purchase at any of our thousands of stores nationwide! You also have the option of returning items by mail - just follow the instructions provided with your order.
If you have any questions, contact us at 1-877-474-6379 or CustomerService@csr.payless.com. We're here to help!
(based on 12 reviews)
of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
50% (6 reviews)
Most Liked Positive Review
Plain but great classic style
I just love the classic plain and simple styling and they look great with my skinny jeans. The problem however is that they are cut too low and do not completely cover my toes...Read complete review
I just love the classic plain and simple styling and they look great with my skinny jeans. The problem however is that they are cut too low and do not completely cover my toes and that is why I had to return them.
Most Liked Negative Review
Cute but Painful
I bought the black lace version of this shoe a few months ago for a special outing with my hubby. I loved the look of the lace and when I tried them on in...Read complete review
I bought the black lace version of this shoe a few months ago for a special outing with my hubby. I loved the look of the lace and when I tried them on in the store, they felt pretty comfortable. However, after only about an hour of wearing them and only walking a little bit in them my heels and the tops of my toes were on fire from rubbing against the stiff outer edge of the shoe. Even though I was wearing footie socks in the shoes I still got blisters. I tried to wear them again a few weeks after that, but quickly regretted my decision. I can't wear these shoes without pain, which is a shame considering they're flats. In fact, I'd choose any of my 4 inch heels over these flats for comfort.
Reviewed by 12 customers
Displaying reviews 1-10
Back to top
Previous | Next »
from Annapolis, MD
Comments about American Eagle Women's Flora Flat:
Love these shoes. So comfortable. Wear them to work all the time. Def keep up with my schedule and sooo cute.
Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Was this review helpful? Yes / No
- You may also flag this review
(5 of 6 customers found this review helpful)
I bought these shoes because I needed a pair of comfortable flats that I could easily toss on whenever I needed to look formal. It was a big mistake. I ordered the black version online because it was really cheap at the time. I bought it for 9 dollars. I wish now that I had waited to try them on in the store. Maybe I would have noticed how uncomfortable you would feel immediately after putting these stiff shoes on. That was probably why they were selling it for so cheap. I wouldn't recommend this product to anyone for any reason.
Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend
Merchant response: Hello - We appreciate this feedback and apologize for the discomfort that you experienced while wearing these flats. Please know that you may exchange or return them at any Payless location regardless of wear.
(11 of 12 customers found this review helpful)
Size down - these run big
from Columbus OH
Ordered the stripe in my typical size 7M but they're too big by at least 1/2 size. I returned to the store but they didn't have this in the store to exchange.Ordered another pr same stripe size 6.5M - hopefully this size will fit better. I do recommend these b/c they are really cute but size down.
Merchant response: Hello - We appreciate this feedback and your comments will be forwarded to our Buying and Merchandising departments for further review.
(17 of 17 customers found this review helpful)
Love That Red
from New Jersey
Often I like colors that really stand out. These flats in red sure do that. The red color is really lush and intense, and provides a bright, happy contrast to jeans. They're also comfy, so they're lots of fun to wear.
(41 of 43 customers found this review helpful)
(36 of 50 customers found this review helpful)
Passing Mine on or Tossing 'Em
[If you see a similar review on another pair, it's because I posted this to the wrong shoe and don't seemed to be able to delete. I reported it but....]I only need to wear shoes at most a couple times a year, so I went to Payless. Out of the flats, their American Eagle brand has the most toe room. I tried it on a couple of times and it seemed fine. (I don't remember if I walked in it or just stood.)Anyway, after walking around with it on in the house, one side was irritating my Achilles heel. I put a band-aid over the area and it was fine. However, an hour or so later, my feet were hurting. While the soles are somewhat flexible, they are still stiff. I'm not used to shoes restricting my feet's freedom. When I'm not barefoot, I'm usually wearing my minimalist-style sneakers - they're like lightweight slippers with great grip. I just bought some Foldable Flats hoping for more comfort.Also, the material on the inside (insole) and the outer sole are slippery. Perhaps because of that, one side has a dent at the bottom because my heel kept pressing it down.
Merchant response: Hello - Thank you for reaching out to us about this. I apologize for the issues that you experienced with your shoes and I will forward your comments to our Quality Assurance department. Please know that you may exchange or return your shoes at any Payless location.
(16 of 21 customers found this review helpful)
Just bought these, OMG they are so cute - My new fav flat!
(16 of 25 customers found this review helpful)
Cute everyday shoe
from Shelby Township, MI
These fit in my regular size and even had a little extra room so I inserted a back heel pad. The pink is a very bright candy hot pink so it might look funny on an older lady.
(23 of 27 customers found this review helpful)
Don't be fooled
from Louisville, KY
Flats are new to me . I wear a size 12 / 12W in heels so I tried on the 12 W and they fell off my feet . After trying the 12W I tried on the 11W and they felt great in the store , easy to walk in and looked great on me. The problem came after wearing them several hours , they began to hurt the soles of my feet. . To be fair to Payless this may have been due to sweat or not being used to wearing flats. I do plan to try them again because they do look soooo great with my denim skirt . I will take another pair of shoes with me just incase .
(36 of 38 customers found this review helpful)
from Chicago, IL
I bought the floral flats and I love them! They are really comfortable and they fit really well. I would recommend these if you're looking for cute and comfortable flats :)
Join our email list to receive special offers