shop by category
shop by size
shop by age
Our structured satchels will add a littleladylike appeal to your office look.
Your favorite shoes: on sale now!
AMERICAN EAGLE BY PAYLESS IS NOT A PRODUCT OF AMERICAN EAGLE OUTFITTERS.
Whatever the reason, you can return it – no questions, no problem!
It's the quick, easy and free Return Policy you'll only find at Payless. Return or exchange your Payless.com purchase at any of our thousands of stores nationwide! You also have the option of returning items by mail - just follow the instructions provided with your order.
If you have any questions, contact us at 1-877-474-6379 or CustomerService@csr.payless.com. We're here to help!
(based on 42 reviews)
of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
100% (7 reviews)
71% (30 reviews)
Feels Too Small
Feels True to Size
100% (13 reviews)
Feels Too Large
Most Liked Positive Review
Hit and Miss...
Buried on the last page of my size I came across these awesome mary janes. With a classic silhouette, offset strap, almond toe, and button detail I had to order a pair....Read complete review
Buried on the last page of my size I came across these awesome mary janes. With a classic silhouette, offset strap, almond toe, and button detail I had to order a pair. I usually check out the quality in the local stores and then order online once satisfied, as size 13 is rarely stocked in store. However since these are online only I didn't have that luxury but decided to place an order anyway.Once the shoes arrived, I was disappointed to find that they were packed in a large universal shoebox, which caused them to bounce and slide around against one another en route to me. Thankfully they were undamaged but it left me wondering if these are extremely old warehouse stock or in fact a new style. I was also initially disappointed in the quality. At first glance these are shoes of the old Payless lower-quality standard with thin man-made uppers and even thinner foam insoles. Years ago when shoes like this could be had from Payless for less than $12 this wouldn't be an issue, but these were more than twice that price. Also I expect shoes purchased at full price, from a retailer, to come in a proper shoebox.After wearing them for awhile I can say that they're not as bad as I first expected. They fit great and are very supportive although I'm expecting to have to use an insole once the footbed starts to degrade from wear. The only real issue is that these should be $20 shoes, max. At the time I ordered they were pushing up near $30 which is just too much for quality lower than what I expect from Payless these days.With that said, I do really like them and they fit well with my casual business ensemble. As always, thanks to Payless for keeping larger sized guys and gals in mind when it comes to heeled footwear.
Most Liked Negative Review
These shoes are SO cute, but UNCOMFORTABLE. When I tried them on, they felt great, but the first time I wore them, I couldn't even get from my car to the store...Read complete review
These shoes are SO cute, but UNCOMFORTABLE. When I tried them on, they felt great, but the first time I wore them, I couldn't even get from my car to the store without my feet hurting. I thought it was only because I wasn't used to heels, but after 2 hours of wearing them while I was sitting down, I had to take them off. I didn't do much walking in them, but the balls of my feet got blistered from the lack of padding. The heel on the left shoe felt like it was going to come off. I'm really not happy because I can't afford to buy shoes often, and these brand new beauties are unwearable. Total waste of money.
Reviewed by 42 customers
Displaying reviews 1-10
Back to top
Previous | Next »
Most comfortable heel I've owned!
By Kay Nicole
from Macon, GA
Comments about American Eagle Women's Kim Button Mary Jane:
I don't wear heels much, and I have flat feet (no arches), so extended wear of this shoe can make my feet hurt a lot. But even so, the shoe is still more comfortable than other heels I've worn. Doesn't dig into my feet, no sliding, not much jamming of the toes; I love this shoe and would most certainly recommend it!
Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Was this review helpful? Yes / No
- You may also flag this review
from Cambridge, WI
They were to big in the heel and the strap was too loose. Would have liked it to be adjustable
very nice shoe
By big feet
from Louisville, KY
To be honest this was truly an impulse buy. I thought they were cute, so I bought them. I really wasn't looking for heels at the time. Just couldn't resist them. And after ordering two pairs of boots, I needed something like this in the online shopping cart.
(2 of 2 customers found this review helpful)
By Vintage Lover
from North Carolina
I wear these shoes with several outfits and a few of my vintage dresses they are very cute I had to put pads in the balls of my feet though so I can stand in them for quite some time but they are not bad shoes!!!
(8 of 9 customers found this review helpful)
Men, This delightful shoe is a "Must Have."
By General Patent
from Saginaw, Michigan
I just picked up my pretty new "Kim" Button Mary Jane high heel pumps today and they are a delight! I ordered them in The black patent finish, which I am fond of. Normally, I order my high heel pumps in a wide width, but had to try a regular width in these shoes. They are built on a fairly wide last, so the size 13 regular fit my man sized 11D feet quite well. This shoe is very pretty and feminine and is sure to make the magic happen when you slip your feet into them and take your first steps. If you order your "Kim" pumps two sizes larger than your man`s size, they will fit you fine. I also love the Mary Jane strap, which is permanently attached to the shoe with a little stretch built in, so they are functional, too! The feel of the strap across your foot is pleasant, also. Gentlemen, If you are looking for a fun time, pretty little high heel that you can wear all day and walk in with total comfort, this is the shoe that belongs in your collection. Although the heel on the 'Kim" is a tad bit blocky in shape, it is still quite feminine looking and gives good stability to the shoe. Ladies, It goes without saying that you will surely enjoy wearing these pretty pumps also. I`m wearing them on my man size feet right now and they are so pretty and feminine looking that I don`t want to take them off. Try em, You`ll like em!
they are fairly comfortable, I could wear all day could use a little cushion in them but not bad. Would probably buy another pair.
(1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)
Perfect work heel!
By Working Mama
from Calabasas, CA
Can walk all day in these shoes without my feet hurting before I get home
My 2nd Pair
from Los Angeles
I love these so much I am buying my 2nd pair. The only reason I do not give all 5 stars is because I have to buy a 2nd pair! They are not durable. I have had my 1st pair for about 8 months. However, yes, I do wear them a lot. I get many compliments on them and because of that feel embarrassed to wear them on their worn out condition.
Picky About My Shoes
from Florence, SC
I have the worst time finding a pair of shoes that fit right, look good and are comfortable. Most of the time I settle for a pair of shoes and they end up being worn once then in my closet they go. However, these shoes have been well worn and loved!! I get compliments all the time on them and I could wear them all day and my feet not hurt!!
from El Paso TX
I would like that those shoes or any other pump heels come in 10 1/2 size. I love this kind of heels. I don't wear high heels. I prefer heels like this or lower.
Merchant response: I have forwarded your comments to the appropriate department. We appreciate hearing from our customers. We are always looking for opportunities to serve our customers better. Thank you for your business and loyalty to Payless ShoeSource.
Join our email list to receive special offers