shop by category
shop by size
shop by age
Our structured satchels will add a littleladylike appeal to your office look.
Your favorite shoes: on sale now!
AMERICAN EAGLE BY PAYLESS IS NOT A PRODUCT OF AMERICAN EAGLE OUTFITTERS.
Whatever the reason, you can return it – no questions, no problem!
It's the quick, easy and free Return Policy you'll only find at Payless. Return or exchange your Payless.com purchase at any of our thousands of stores nationwide! You also have the option of returning items by mail - just follow the instructions provided with your order.
If you have any questions, contact us at 1-877-474-6379 or CustomerService@csr.payless.com. We're here to help!
(based on 31 reviews)
of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
94% (29 reviews)
Most Liked Positive Review
The perfect pump...
This is an ideal shoe style for anyone wanting a cute shoe without the problems stemming from a very high heel. It's the perfect height for all day wear, right out of the...Read complete review
This is an ideal shoe style for anyone wanting a cute shoe without the problems stemming from a very high heel. It's the perfect height for all day wear, right out of the box. No sore feet, blisters or other problems. And the look is cute as a button. Why I didn't try these sooner is beyond me.You may notice the "quality" rating is only 4 stars. This is NOT because of the fit, quality or comfort. If the heel tips were rubber (like the soles) instead of hard plastic (which is slippery on certain floors), this category would also have been rated a 5 star.But that issue's easy to fix -- I just have to be careful until I can get to a shoe shop (soon) and have the plastic replaced. Just a pet peeve of mine!Buy a pair, girls. I love mine, bet you will, too!
Most Liked Negative Review
People with wide feet beware
Mary Janes are my favorite shoes and I was really excited to find these on payless but was disappointed when I received them. The strap going over the foot was just too small. I...Read complete review
Mary Janes are my favorite shoes and I was really excited to find these on payless but was disappointed when I received them. The strap going over the foot was just too small. I ordered them in wide but there was no way they were going to fit. Otherwise totally awesome shoes.
Reviewed by 31 customers
Displaying reviews 1-10
Back to top
Previous | Next »
(1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)
Please Bring These Back!!!
By Julia JO
from New York City
Comments about American Eagle Women's Kimmie Mary Jane Pump:
I bought a pair of these like 3 years ago and have come to really rely on them. They are the best thing I've found to go from street shoes to dancing, and I can wear them all day! Unfortunately, I've worn down the heel on my pair and am wobbling on the nails inside. And they're starting to look pretty beat up and worn out. I've been searching desperately to find something to replace them, but haven't been able to find something similar. Please bring these back, I would buy like 3 more pairs. :(
Was this review helpful? Yes / No
- You may also flag this review
(5 of 6 customers found this review helpful)
Not for me
from Germantown, MD
I don't know how and I don't know why, but it hurts. The style and everything is excellent, but I walked down the street for like 30 minutes and my feet started aching. The size is true and my feet are average Asian, not wide. I feel bad to return them because I like them so much.
Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Merchant response: Hello - I apologize for the issues you experienced with your shoes and I will forward your comments to our Quality Assurance department for further review. Please know that you may exchange or return your shoes at any Payless location.
(16 of 17 customers found this review helpful)
A Must Have Mary Jane
from Northern Virginia
Recently, my wife and I watched the Downton Abbey series and, while not a big fan of the show itself, I became enthralled with the fashions it portrayed. Thus when I came across these I just had to buy them.As for the look, the round toe, the wide strap with circular buckle, the stacked cone heels, and the black (non-patent) leather texture with visible stitching gives it that retro Roaring Twenties look to which I have become partial.As for the feel, even though I usually require a wide width shoe, the round toe provides ample room in the toe box in a regular width. Also, the elastic band to which the buckle is connected stretches enough to allow slipping the shoes on and off without unbuckling them, while still keeping them snug during normal wear. And walking is easy because not only is the heel a moderate two and a half inches, but since its cone shape places the pivot point slightly further forward than a normal heel it requires less force to rotate your foot when taking a step--thus making the heels feel even shorter than they actually are. But enough of the physics lesson. Lastly the insole is so comfortable that sometimes I nearly forget that I'm wearing a heeled shoe.The only downside to this shoe is I don't like the hound's tooth pattern on the insole. But since you can't see it when you're wearing them, that's just one more reason to keep these amazing, gorgeous shoes on your feet.In conclusion, this shoe is a fabulous blast from the past that fuses form and function in an incredible combination of beauty and comfort that would make any lady (or in my case, lord) feel like a queen.
Images shared by HighHeelsAficionado
H.M.S. -- Her (or His) Majesty's Shoes
(7 of 10 customers found this review helpful)
I have had my Kimmie Mary Janes for a couple years now, and although I dont wear them as often as I should, Im still amazed at how comfy they are every time I put them on!they are cute, stylish & classic Mary Janes (never go out of style) and go perfet with jeans, skirts or even when lounging in a night shirtso to women or guy who has not got around to getting these wonderful heels, stop hesitating & go get them you wont be disappointed!!!
(6 of 6 customers found this review helpful)
My go-to black heels
from East Coast
I never wear heels except for once a year when we go to my husbands work Christmas party because they kill my feet. Decided to give these a try a few years ago and they are now one of my favorite pairs of shoes. They go with everything and best of all they don't kill my feet. I'm actually contemplating buying another pair for when mine get worn out, that's how much I love them.
(13 of 13 customers found this review helpful)
Please Bring Back This Shoe :(
It is literally the only shoe I can wear to work that doesn't destroy my feet. I have owned at least 4 pairs of these and they are so rad.Honestly, you have to bring these back. It is just bad customer service not to.
(20 of 20 customers found this review helpful)
My favorite work heel
Payless. Payless, please. Please bring this shoe back.This is the only - and I mean only - heel I'll wear to work.I will literally pay you to bring this shoe back. Well, okay maybe I won't pay you - but you get our point:AMERICA LOVES THIS SHOE.
(15 of 15 customers found this review helpful)
Bring Back This Wonderful Mary Jane
I have owned about 6 pairs of this shoe and am dreading having to look for a replacement if this shoe is out of stock forever. I have a narrow foot and need a stylish shoe with a strap. This shoe is perfect. It is comfortable and fits my narrow foot. Please don't stop carrying this shoe.
(12 of 12 customers found this review helpful)
PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE BRING THESE SHOES BACK!!!
I've purchased these shoes twice before and went looking for them but you don't carry them anymore!!! They're super comfortable and yet stylish...please BRING THEM BACK!!
PLEASE bring these back!!
from Houston, TX
I have difficulty finding heels that are cute AND comfortable, and these are the best of both!! I am 4' 9" tall, so my wearing heels is a real plus!! I have had these shoes for some time and I have worn them ALOT - they still look great and the heel is intact (in many of my heels the sole wears down, not on these!!
Join our email list to receive special offers