shop by category
shop by size
shop by age
Our structured satchels will add a littleladylike appeal to your office look.
Your favorite shoes: on sale now!
AMERICAN EAGLE BY PAYLESS IS NOT A PRODUCT OF AMERICAN EAGLE OUTFITTERS.
Whatever the reason, you can return it – no questions, no problem!
It's the quick, easy and free Return Policy you'll only find at Payless. Return or exchange your Payless.com purchase at any of our thousands of stores nationwide! You also have the option of returning items by mail - just follow the instructions provided with your order.
If you have any questions, contact us at 1-877-474-6379 or CustomerService@csr.payless.com. We're here to help!
(based on 21 reviews)
of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
76% (16 reviews)
Most Liked Positive Review
I normally don't wear open toe shoes but was forced to when I injured my toe. I liked this style and headed to Payless to check it out. With the BOGO sale I got...Read complete review
I normally don't wear open toe shoes but was forced to when I injured my toe. I liked this style and headed to Payless to check it out. With the BOGO sale I got a black and tan pair. By summers end they were on sale for $9 and I restocked for next summer with a black, tan, and red pair. I've worn the red ones so I'm ordering another pair for next summer. Don't want to ever be without them. Excellent fit, price, and they wear well with anything I put on. Please keep them in stock!
Most Liked Negative Review
Worst Sandals Ever! Do Not Buy
These are the worse sandals I've ever owned. I actually had high hopes for these and had the store order them for me so that I could ensure that I got the right size....Read complete review
These are the worse sandals I've ever owned. I actually had high hopes for these and had the store order them for me so that I could ensure that I got the right size. I thought that the molded foot bed would provide ultimate comfort, and I bought them with the hopes of wearing them through the airport on an upcoming trip. I wouldn't wear these shoes to the end of the block! The shoes come off the feet while walking, at one point, the shoes were about 3 inches ahead of my foot and after wearing them all day it was too painful to hold the shoe on my foot with my toes. I thought I just had to tighten the strap, but nope, that didn't help. And I was content with walking like that because it was the least painful. The part that goes between the toes was very painful and just after 30 minutes of wearing them, I immediately regretted my decision to wear them to work. The look of these shoes was absolutely great, I got the black patent. And I am so disappointed that they hurt my feet so much. I will be returning them.
Reviewed by 21 customers
Displaying reviews 1-10
Back to top
Previous | Next »
(1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)
Best Sandal Ever
Comments about American Eagle Women's Sage Flat Sandal:
Please bring these sandals back for 2017, they are the most comfortable ones ever and are a great knockoff for Birckenstocks!
Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Was this review helpful? Yes / No
- You may also flag this review
Love the Look
By Happy Camper
I purchased a pair of them at the beginning of summer and they have been my go to shoe. They are very confortable. They are so convenient to just slip on to run errands or whatever else you may need to do. I also was very lucky to get them on sale so it makes it a lot more exciting.
They slip off our feet
By Longtime Payless Shopper
from Bronx, NY
The midline part slips to the side while walking and the shoe slips off your feet while walking as well.
Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend
These are super comfortable even when worn for extended periods of time.
love love love on my third pair
from New York
they are super cute and so comfortable so mad they are running out of my sizes on my third pair. the black patent are hot
(9 of 11 customers found this review helpful)
from Washington, DC
Merchant response: Hello - Thank you for providing this feedback. We are truly sorry about the discomfort that you experienced with these shoes and your comments will be forwarded to our Quality Assurance department for further review. Please know that you may exchange or return the shoes at any Payless location, regardless of wear.
(5 of 6 customers found this review helpful)
Worst Shoe I've ever owned!!!
from Janesville, WI
I tried this shoe on in the store to get the correct size and then placed the order online as the store did not have the color I wanted in stock. Trying on a shoe in the store may ensure that you order the correct size however unless you spend a half hour walking around the store you are not guaranteed comfort. These shoes do not stay on my feet. When I walk they shoot out ahead of my foot and it is terribly uncomfortable. Naturally you would assume I purchased the shoe too big, but if I try on a smaller shoe which I went a did just for fun my heal rests on the raised back of the shoe causing great discomfort to the heel. This is all around the worst shoe I have ever purchased and because I have already worn them outside I do not have the option of returning them. So disappointing!!!!
Merchant response: Hello - We are truly sorry about the for the discomfort that you experienced with these sandals and your comments will be forwarded to our Quality Assurance department for further review. Please know that you may exchange or return the shoes at any Payless location, regardless of wear.
(7 of 8 customers found this review helpful)
cute but uncomfortable
I really wanted to like these Birkenstock gizeh knock offs. They look nice in the brown I ordered, but they are not comfortable at all. First of all, the foot bed is all wrong. Where there should be a hollow in the heel area, there is a big oval of padding instead. This negates any arch support, so you don't get the comfort and support you would expect with a molded/contoured cork foot bed. And without the molded foot bed they feel like they are going to fall off. I kept wanting to move my foot forward or backward in the sandal to make it feel better but nothing worked. But the worst part is that the strap rubbed the inside arch area really bad. I tried adjusting it and it didn't help. I've worn other Birk knock offs that were plenty comfortable (and cheap) so this is just a design issue. Too bad, because they are nice looking.
Merchant response: Hello - We sincerely apologize for the discomfort that you experienced with these shoes. Please know that you may exchange or return the shoes at any Payless location regardless of wear. Your comments will be forwarded to our Buying and Merchandising departments for further review.
(9 of 10 customers found this review helpful)
I just received mine and I loved everything about this sandal. I ordered my usual size in brown and my foot fit too snuggly inside the footbed. Even though it fit I still re-ordered one size up because I wanted more of a relaxed fit. The material is very flexible on top and the bottom feels very soft, so soft that its resistance to everyday wear concerns me. I would suggest to order a size up. I'm really excited that I have found a staple sandal and hopefully it lasts a couple years. If not I also ordered a backup pair. For the price I think it's worth it. No more worrying with this sandal because it goes with everything and it's my only pair!
(8 of 9 customers found this review helpful)
I can't stop wearing these. My regular size is 8.5 but those were kind of tight, go a size up and ultimate comfort.
Join our email list to receive special offers