shop by category
shop by size
shop by age
Our structured satchels will add a littleladylike appeal to your office look.
Your favorite shoes: on sale now!
AMERICAN EAGLE BY PAYLESS IS NOT A PRODUCT OF AMERICAN EAGLE OUTFITTERS.
Whatever the reason, you can return it – no questions, no problem!
It's the quick, easy and free Return Policy you'll only find at Payless. Return or exchange your Payless.com purchase at any of our thousands of stores nationwide! You also have the option of returning items by mail - just follow the instructions provided with your order.
If you have any questions, contact us at 1-877-474-6379 or CustomerService@csr.payless.com. We're here to help!
(based on 18 reviews)
of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
78% (14 reviews)
Feels Too Small
Feels True to Size
100% (5 reviews)
Feels Too Large
Most Liked Positive Review
Regarding Breaking In
I read a few of the reviews and some of you said things like, "after the break in" or "The break in period." Ladies!! You are NOT...Read complete review
I read a few of the reviews and some of you said things like, "after the break in" or "The break in period." Ladies!! You are NOT supposed to "break in" a pair of shoes! If the shoes don't feel comfortable when you first try them on then they are Not the right size or they are not made right. Don't let anyone tell you that you have to "break in" a pair of shoes because they are uninformed and they don't know what they are talking about. Be good to your feet ladies!
Most Liked Negative Review
Sizing is off
I have purchase quite a few pair from this brand but recently the sizing are off. I wear an eleven and my feet are swimming in these. I tried to size down to a...Read complete review
I have purchase quite a few pair from this brand but recently the sizing are off. I wear an eleven and my feet are swimming in these. I tried to size down to a 10 since they are no half sizes but they hurt my feet. Wish I was able to continue getting this brand...oh well.
Reviewed by 18 customers
Displaying reviews 1-10
Back to top
Previous | Next »
(21 of 25 customers found this review helpful)
from Clarkesville, IN
Comments about American Eagle Women's Ainsley Flat:
Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Was this review helpful? Yes / No
- You may also flag this review
(21 of 24 customers found this review helpful)
Really like the bow!
I normally go for more plain flats, but the bow on these shoes is a fun detail without being really in your face cutesey. I got the red ones, and can't wait to wear them with my mostly black and gray work dresses.
(26 of 57 customers found this review helpful)
First time for me to buy flat girl shoes. As a guy, I usually prefer high heels, but those shoes are so girly. I bought the leopard, and it is also very cute. Very confy, and I think I should buy the blue one also. Not going well with a skirt, but very ok with my androgyn style when in jeans.
(17 of 19 customers found this review helpful)
from woodland, ca]
I bought a size 7.5 regular even though I am technically a 7.5W these fit very comfortably they don't dig in the heal or by my toes at all which is something I appreciate a lot. Normally I have to buy a size 8 because it is hard to find W shoes but the regular 7.5 fit just fine, it did take a few days to break in properly but they were not uncomfortable to wear for the break in period. I usually wear mine about 12 hours and walk around a lot and yes my feet do get tired because there is no support but that's ok because I prefer lack of support in flats then having to wear high heels for work. I do recommend these to be work with the flat socks just to keep your feet from feeling grimy after long periods of wear without washing because who has time for washing flats all the time.
(61 of 80 customers found this review helpful)
from Masontown, PA
(37 of 38 customers found this review helpful)
from Rural PA
I wear a 13 so finding cute, comfortable shoes at an affordable price has been a lifelong issue. Problem solved with these. I have never had to go through a break-in period and have worn these shoes all day with no pain. I have very flat feet and these have not caused me any support problems. I have even worn these while walking for exercise when opportunities arose & I didn't have my athletic shoes. Cute, comfortable, affordable & sturdy.
(18 of 20 customers found this review helpful)
fit great if...you change sizes
I went to the store, a size 7 hurt my feet (7 is my true size) a 7w was too loose but a 6 1/2 w was just right, fit perfect, comfortable. I am going to buy 2 more pairs.
(20 of 25 customers found this review helpful)
I bought the multi-color flats, and although they're really cute, they're also really uncomfortable. The back of the right shoe rubs against the back of my foot and makes them painful to wear. I couldn't last more than an hour in these. I would return them in a heartbeat if I hadn't already worn them out. Definitely do not recommend
Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend
(20 of 20 customers found this review helpful)
from Las Vegas, NV
I went into Payless one day looking for my daughter a pair of shoes and ran across these beauties. I purchased the black and white pair and I love them! I use to be a high heels woman but since having 4 kids I am now mini van soccer mom and need comfort when I'm out and about with small kids. I bought a cheap pair of simple flats from them before and wasn't impressed. After buying these though I am now a ballet flats wearing woman from now on. These are very stylish and cute. I found them more supportive then the cheaper ones I bought so my feet do not hurt even after walking around for several hours. I wish they came in grey or brown because I would love another pair but I'm not sold on the other colors. These were worth the money though and I would definitely recommend.
(21 of 22 customers found this review helpful)
These flats are adorable. I love the bow on the front and the overall style. They do seem to run a little large as I have a pair of similar AE flats in the same size that were a little snug. Normally, I wear an 11 W (if available) and I feel like I'm swimming in these compared to my other shoes. It might be something to consider when choosing a size.
Join our email list to receive special offers