shop by category
shop by size
shop by age
Our structured satchels will add a littleladylike appeal to your office look.
Your favorite shoes: on sale now!
AMERICAN EAGLE BY PAYLESS IS NOT A PRODUCT OF AMERICAN EAGLE OUTFITTERS.
Whatever the reason, you can return it – no questions, no problem!
It's the quick, easy and free Return Policy you'll only find at Payless. Return or exchange your Payless.com purchase at any of our thousands of stores nationwide! You also have the option of returning items by mail - just follow the instructions provided with your order.
If you have any questions, contact us at 1-877-474-6379 or CustomerService@csr.payless.com. We're here to help!
(based on 66 reviews)
of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
100% (6 reviews)
74% (49 reviews)
Feels Too Small
Feels True to Size
100% (23 reviews)
Feels Too Large
Most Liked Positive Review
Great Shoe and Purchase!!!
I am EXTREMELY happy with these shoes! I measure for a size 6 and had to size up to a 6 1/2 but other than that everything is great! They are extremely comfortable...Read complete review
I am EXTREMELY happy with these shoes! I measure for a size 6 and had to size up to a 6 1/2 but other than that everything is great! They are extremely comfortable and breathable and don't squish your toes. I got them in both cobalt suede and menswear and love both! The menswear is more padded and thicker and the cobalt is thinner but both are equally comfortable and look great! I strongly recommend this shoe to anyone looking for a great flat!
Most Liked Negative Review
I really really want to like these, but....
I bought these shoes to replace a pair that had finally given up the ghost after almost daily wearing for 4 years or so. I stopped into Payless and had to decide between these...Read complete review
I bought these shoes to replace a pair that had finally given up the ghost after almost daily wearing for 4 years or so. I stopped into Payless and had to decide between these and a couple of other similar pairs.These shoes are so cute. They're a cute flat black that goes with just about anything.I have a couple of problems with them.First is sizing: my normal size is just a smidge too big; the next size down is waaaaay too small.The second problem is the band of material that runs along the top of the shoe. It sits around the top and ends up digging into my ankle and my foot, to the point where I have to wear heel inserts and moleskin. If that little strip of material were gone, these shoes would be perfect!
Reviewed by 66 customers
Displaying reviews 1-10
Back to top
Previous | Next »
Comments about American Eagle Women's Bayley Twist Flat:
I have a hard time finding shoes i like.I love this shoe . Every year i buy 3 pairs at a time just for bsckbup. Please bring this shoe back! It was cute and i could wear it with jeans or my dress work pants.
Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Was this review helpful? Yes / No
- You may also flag this review
Please bring back this shoe!
By Bayley Twists 4EVER
Please bring back this shoe! I would buy many pairs - very comfortable and perfect for the office!
Where did this shoe go!!??!!
from Jax, FL
I don't know where this shoe went or why.... but it's the only shoe I wear. I own 10 pair of the same shoe and I swear I wear them everyday. I have pictures to prove it! LOL! Then one day... poof... they are not sold anymore. Please please please... bring this shoe back. It's sold out for a reason.
Images shared by AJ
Trying my best to keep them clean and in good shape!
(3 of 3 customers found this review helpful)
Why did you get rid of these?
from Albany, NY
I don't know why pay-less ever stopped carrying these, I bought the other pair that are supposed to be like these and they are horrible, they are too tight and are not flexible like these are. Please bring them back... I should have bought 20 when I had the chance...
Love this shoe
Love these shoes!!!!!! Please please when will you have them stock ive looked everywhere
Best flat I have ever owned!
By Flat lover!
These are very much the best flat I have ever owned and I am a die hard flat owner! I never wear heels or any other shoe so I know how to compare flats! I wish Payless would carry these again! I have wide feet and theses have been my go-to flats for awhile now! I have two pairs! I love these flats!
(1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)
These are my favorite flats.
I own these shoes in black, dark teal and navy floral. I bought these but did not have high expectations for the shoes. They have been so comfortable and are great for standing on my feet all day. My only real complaint now is that the shoe isn't being carried in as many varieties as the past. I would love to see my colors or patterns offered. Thank Payless!
Best ballet flat I've ever owned
from Cincinnati, Ohio
I've had a pair of these for years. I wear them all the time, they are my go to flat. I couldn't remember where I had bought my orginal pair, I was so excited when I discovered they came from Payless and are still being made. I'm on my second pair, and will most likely be buying a third just incase they discontinue them. These flats are so comfortable, it almost feels like you're not wearing shoes. They've never given me blisters on my heels (a problem I have with lost evert flat I've tried). They can be dressed up or down, and look just as good paired with a dress or jeans and a tee shirt. My only complaint is the black fades if you wear them a lot. But overall these are my all time favorite pair of shoes.
The irreplaceable shoes
from san pedro
I love love love these shoes but they never have them in my size in the store or online I desperately need new ones.
My Go-To Purchase Constantly Buying Though
from Columbus, Ga
I am constantly buying these shoes. The only problem is that I am constantly buying them. I go through at least 9 pairs a year. They tear easily. They are very comfortable and match almost any outfit and come in a variety of colors and being a size 13 it's hard to find consistently comfortable shoes, I just wish the quality was better so I didn't have to go through so many pairs of them.
Join our email list to receive special offers